Nature Canada
Canada Warbler. Credit: Jeff Nadler

What’s In the Federal Government’s Proposed Incidental Take Permitting Regime?

On November 7th, 2026 the federal government provided notice that it intended to propose changes to the Migratory Birds Regulations to create a permitting system for the incidental take of migratory birds in Canada in relation to Projects Of National Interest. Incidental take refers to the unintentional but foreseeable killing or harming of birds during otherwise lawful activities. Currently, under the Migratory Birds Convention Act (MBCA) and Migratory Birds Regulations 2022 (MBR 2022) migratory birds, their nests, and their eggs are protected from harm, although the protections for nests vary depending on the circumstances and species. Despite these legal protections, enforcement has been inadequate, and the law has not provided the conservation outcomes that it should.

While the idea of creating a system to issue permits for the killing of migratory birds may at first seem antithetical to the goal of bird conservation, Nature Canada and other environmental organizations have supported the principle of an incidental take permitting system. This is because the current system is poorly enforced and difficult to enforce effectively. As a result, activities that harm migratory birds often take place without meaningful accountability. By creating a permitting system, incidental take could be better regulated and monitored and ultimately result in better population level outcomes for migratory birds. However, for this system to work, it is imperative that it be designed with the goal of improving outcomes for birds from the start, not simply make it easier for projects to proceed.

Canada Warbler. Credit: Jeff Nadler
Canada Warbler. Credit: Jeff Nadler

The federal government has been attempting to create an incidental take permitting system for over 30 years. Major efforts to do so stalled in the early 2000s but were revived in 2023 when Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC) began consultations with stakeholders and rights holders, including Nature Canada. Those consultations took place in 2023, 2025, and 2026 where the government heard repeatedly that any new permitting system should:

  • Be risk-based and proportional to the impacts on migratory birds;
  • Focus on population-level conservation outcomes for migratory birds;
  • Deliver a net benefit for migratory birds through monitoring, data collection, conservation offsets, and by directing fees toward conservation and mitigation;
  • Address major causes of indirect mortality such as building collisions, powerlines, and communication towers;
  • Be fully enforceable and focused on activities that are of high risk to migratory bird conservation.

This and other feedback was reported by ECCC on their webpage Continued Modernization of the Migratory Birds Regulations. The broader proposed incidental take permitting regime is expected to be published in fall of 2027 or early 2028 with a 60-day public consultation period.

The proposed regulations that are currently under public consultation would create a new authorization process for the incidental take of migratory birds for Projects of National Interest (PONI) that have been listed under Schedule I of the Building Canada Act (BCA) – otherwise known as Bill C-5. Current PONIs include the Pacific Link (West Coast Oil Pipeline) and Roberts Bank Terminal 2. The proposed regulations set out one criterion for the authorizations of incidental take of migratory birds:

  • All reasonable measures will be taken to avoid and minimize adverse impacts on migratory birds, and their nests and eggs.

The BCA is intended to streamline federal project approvals for PONIs by providing conditional upfront approval of federal authorizations listed in Schedule 2 of the Act at the outset of the project approval process. The MBCA and MBR 2022 are listed in Schedule 2 meaning that authorizations for incidental take could be granted through the BCA process, with detailed, binding conditions developed afterward. While we appreciate the inclusion of the “avoid and minimize” language which mirrors that of the first two steps of the mitigation hierarchy, we are concerned that the “reasonable measures” language is excessively broad and undefined. Without clear standards for what constitutes reasonable measures, and a requirement for adequate environmental assessments and bird surveys before activities are authorized, how can the government determine whether harm to migratory birds has been sufficiently avoided or minimized?

On a more positive note, the proposed permits would be subject to a fee system, a portion of which would be allocated towards funding a conservation credit system to support migratory bird conservation work, intended to serve as an offset to any harms. However details of this are sparse. The proposal does not specify what the permitting fees would be or what portion of those fees would support conservation work. It is also unclear whether those funds would support the conservation of the same bird species that were harmed by the issuance of the permit or whether the conservation benefits would be sufficient to compensate for the damage. Harms to one species can not simply be offset by work to support another.

It is also unclear what sort of monitoring and enforcement systems would be put in place to ensure that project proponents and operators are compliant with their permits. The proposal states simply that authorizations would be subject to “periodic” audits and compliance verification. Non-compliance could result in penalties, suspension, or cancellation of the authorization. But how often would audits take place, what monitoring would be required, and would the results be made public? Considering the longstanding challenges with enforcing existing protections for migratory birds, a new permitting system needs stronger accountability measures, not vague promises of periodic audits.

By creating a special authorization process for National Interest Projects before completing the broader permitting regime, the government risks putting faster project approvals ahead of bird conservation. The federal government has moved ahead with this narrower proposal without incorporating many of the safeguards discussed during earlier consultations, and with a much shorter period for public comment. After years of work on a system intended to improve protection for migratory birds, it is difficult to see how this proposal will deliver better outcomes for birds.

Public consultations close on December 6th, 2026 and can be submitted by email to ConsultationssurleROM-MBRConsultations@ec.gc.ca. Nature Canada is calling on all of our supporters, donors, members and Nature Network partners for their voices to be heard and ensure continued protections for our migratory birds.

What Nature Canada is Calling For

Nature Canada supports an incidental take permitting system that delivers measurable improvements in conservation outcomes for migratory bird populations, but the proposed system for Projects of National Interest needs stronger safeguards. We are calling on the federal government to:

  • Make the mitigation hierarchy mandatory. Project proponents must demonstrate that they have first avoided harm to migratory birds wherever possible, then minimized unavoidable impacts, restored affected habitat where feasible, and compensated for any remaining harm. These steps must be followed in order, not treated as interchangeable options. Compensation must never become a substitute for avoiding harm in the first place.
  • Require bird surveys and impact assessments before harmful activities proceed. Proponents must identify the species, populations and habitats at risk, assess potential impacts, including cumulative impacts, and demonstrate how those impacts will be addressed. No activities that could harm migratory birds should proceed until the necessary surveys and impact assessments have been completed and enforceable mitigation measures are in place.
  • Ensure conservation credits deliver measurable benefits to affected bird populations. Conservation credits must address residual impacts only after all feasible measures to avoid, minimize and restore have been taken. Credits should be linked to the species and populations affected, with clear requirements for additional, measurable conservation benefits and transparent accounting of how funds are spent and what they achieve.
  • Require monitoring, public reporting and enforceable conditions. Every authorization should include project-specific monitoring requirements, regular compliance audits and public reporting of bird mortality and other impacts. Where monitoring reveals greater harm than anticipated, proponents must be required to take additional measures, and the government must have the authority to modify, suspend or revoke authorizations. There must be meaningful consequences for non-compliance.
  • Apply consistent conservation standards to all projects. National Interest Projects should meet the same conservation standards being developed through the broader incidental take permitting process. The designation of a project as being in the national interest should not weaken protections for migratory birds.

Want to Help?

Canada’s wilderness is the world’s envy. It’s our duty to keep our true north strong and green.

Donate